“Do a Good Turn Daily.” The Girl Scouts of America slogan seems quite appropriate for such a vaunted organization. Juliette Gordon Low, or as her friends called her, Daisy, founded the Girl Scouts in the year 1912. She envisioned an association dedicated to the growth of young girls and over the years the scout’s numbers steadily grew.
Juliette Gordon Low declared that the mission of the Girl Scouts would be to “build girls of courage, confidence, and character, who make the world a better place.” However, Daisy had no way of knowing, and could never have envisioned that three beautiful young Girl Scouts would never have the opportunity to make this world a better place. In 1977 those three Girl Scouts were murdered.
How extraordinarily odd, camp counselor Michelle Hoffman thought. Upon returning to her tent she discovered that her belongings were strewn about the inside of the canvass enclosure. Hoffman further found that the contents of a box of donuts had been taken and there inside the box was a scrap of paper.
Unsure of the paper’s purpose she unfolded it and written on it was a message. “We are on a mission to kill three girls in tent one.” Hoffman immediately searched for and found the camp director. Hoffman explained her findings inside her tent and handed the note to the director. She, in turn, told Hoffman that it was obviously a prank, and the note was discarded.
Everything seemed to be just like any other night as the black comforter of darkness covered the Oklahoma landscape in the early morning hours of June 13th. The Girl Scouts were in their tents at Camp Scott in Mayes County, Oklahoma and it seemed as though tranquility and weariness had crept into the minds and bodies of the young girls.
But there was something in the air that night, and it was death. And yes, there were those screams, those terrible screams coming from a tent somewhere in the Kiowa Unit which were heard at around 2:00 a.m.; the bone-chilling screams that were reported to camp counselors. But much like the threatening note found two months earlier, this too was discounted as unimportant. After all, the earlier 11:00 p.m. bed check found nothing out of the ordinary. All the girls were safely tucked into their sleeping bags.
Tent #7 was a four-person tent but only three girls were assigned to sleep there. Doris Denise Milner, 10, Michele Guse, 9, and Lori Lee Farmer, 8 were carefree innocent young girls and so very proud to be Girl Scouts. Each of the girls was so looking forward to the camping adventure. Sadly, none of the girls from Oklahoma would awaken to the morning Sun.
The morning of June 13th arrived and all the Girl Scouts were excited as they prepared to assemble for the morning roll call. That is all save three. One of the camp counselors walked leisurely amidst the tents on her way to the shower. It was nearly 6:00 a.m. when she noticed a sleeping bag that was curiously out of place.
The sleeping bag was lying in a stand of trees located slightly outside the area where the tents were located. As the counselor moved closer to the sleeping bag she saw something that chilled her to the bone. There in the bag was the lifeless body of a young girl, no doubt one of the Girl Scouts.
A frantic search of all the tents led to the discovery that all three campers from tent #7 were unaccounted for. The ensuing search for the missing girls soon resulted in a gruesome discovery. The other two girl’s bodies were found not far from the location where the first girl’s remains were found. According to Camp Administrator Barbara Day, the bodies of those two girls were found inside yet another sleeping bag.
It was apparent that the girls had been appallingly beaten, beaten so savagely that the three were unrecognizable. Subsequent tests would reveal that two had also been raped. How could this have happened? Who raped and murdered those sweet young girls? The sheriff’s department was immediately notified.
The investigation into the murders began and the feelings of shock and sadness that once filled the minds and hearts of those who looked upon the lifeless forms was soon replaced with anger and hatred. The monster that killed those girls must be found and punished and there was hope that the discovery of several things having evidentiary value found at the crime scene would help.
A partial latent fingerprint was found on the lens of a large red flashlight. The flashlight itself was discovered lying on the body of one of the girls. On the blood-washed floor of tent #7 was found a size nine and one-half shoeprint. A local property owner stated that between 2:30 a.m. and 3:00 a.m., he heard what he referred to as “quite a bit of traffic” on a sparsely traveled road near the camp.
The Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation joined the Mayes County Sheriff’s Department in the investigation and a representative was quoted as saying, “apparently from viewing the scene and the bodies the little girls were beaten to death.”
Mayes County Sheriff Pete Weaver couldn’t hide his emotions when issuing his statement. It makes me pretty bitter, very bitter. “I feel like the investigation will bring results. I just don’t think we have that many nuts in this area.
‘I don’t think he, the murderer, was being selective of the girls. I think he was being selective of the tent. It was an end tent and the closest one was fifty to seventy-five feet away.”
For days following the gruesome discovery law enforcement officers combed the area for clues and a suspect. Every shack, barn, and house was searched, and then, and quite expectantly, they got a break. The search of a nearby cave and the discovery of items inside that may have come from the camp ultimately led to the identification of a suspect. That man was Gene Leroy Hart.
Hart was thirty-three years old. He had previously been convicted of burglary and rape and had four years ago escaped from prison and the Mayes County Jail. The search for Hart began and finally, after ten months, Gene Leroy Hart was arrested in a remote shack some fifty miles from the site of the murders.
Judge William J. Whistler presided over the turbulent trial and each day reporters from all over packed the courtroom and grounds outside the courthouse. Hart’s attorney, Garvin Isaacs, continued to state publicly that his client was innocent. There were innuendos that some of the, so called, evidence had been tampered with while other pieces of evidence may have actually been fabricated.
Somewhat surprisingly, Hart garnered quite a bit of support and many felt he was, in fact, innocent. Law enforcement had to admit that they had no physical evidence proving that Hart was the murderer. The lone fingerprint was too smudged to be useful and as for the size nine and one-half shoeprint. Well, Hart did not wear that size shoe.
On March 20, 1979, the jury announced to the judge that they had reached a unanimously agreed-upon verdict. Much to the dismay and even anger of many in attendance the jury announced that their verdict was, not guilty.
However, Gene Leroy Hart was not a free man. Following the jury’s decision the prosecutor, in an attempt to console family members of the girls, reminded them that Hart would be going to prison to finish out his previous sentence. Hart was to serve more than three hundred years.
Years later a DNA test was performed to determine if in fact Hart was the killer. Blood, semen, and hair samples found at the crime scene were analyzed and it was hoped that the results would leave no doubt that Hart was the murderer. The tests, however, found that although it was very likely he murdered the girls the findings could not unequivocally identify him.
Gene Leroy Hart did not spend three hundred years in prison. He died three months after his not-guilty verdict. Some say he was the victim of poisoning but the official cause of death stated that he succumbed to a heart attack.
Michele Guse’s father, Richard later helped pass the state’s “Victims’ Bill of Rights” legislation while Lori Lee Farmer’s mother Sheri, founded the Oklahoma chapter of “Parents of Murdered Children.”
Any thoughts of a restful night’s sleep for the parents of the three murdered girls vanished following their deaths. They found that they were awakened by the terrible thoughts of the fear and pain the three must have endured.
Restful sleep also evaded many of the Girl Scouts who were lucky enough to have survived that dreadful night. They too were awakened from their slumber as the nightmarish memories of those terrible screams that rang out in that dark Oklahoma night plucked them from their sleep.